Sorry, you need to enable JavaScript to visit this website.

dhcf

Department of Health Care Finance - DHCF
 

DC Agency Top Menu

Audits and Investigations

How to Prepare for an Onsite Audit

When an onsite audit is scheduled, the Division of Program Integrity (DPI) works collaboratively with providers to minimize disruption to daily operations and ensure the audit proceeds smoothly. Providers can prepare by taking the following steps:

1. Provide a Suitable Workspace for Auditors

  • Offer a temporary work area that is reasonably close to staff and necessary records.

  • The space should have adequate lighting, room for laptops and files, and allow auditors to review documents comfortably.

  • Since many original records are maintained at the provider location, auditors must be able to access them efficiently.

  • The amount of time auditors spend onsite will vary based on the audit type, sample size, and complexity. DPI will complete as much work offsite as possible to reduce disruptions.

2. Supply a Current Organizational Chart

  • Provide an up‑to‑date organizational chart for the area under review.

  • This helps auditors understand the provider’s administrative structure, staff roles, reporting relationships, and workflow.

  • It also allows auditors to identify who may need to be interviewed for clarification during the audit.

3. Designate a Knowledgeable Staff Member

  • Assign a staff member—such as a Clinical Manager, Clinical Administrator, or an Administrative Staff Person—to serve as the primary point of contact.

  • This individual should be familiar with documentation requirements, billing processes, and day‑to‑day operations.

  • They may be asked to provide records, explain workflows, or coordinate staff availability.

4. Ensure Staff Availability for Process Clarification

  • During the audit, the auditor may need to speak with employees at different levels to better understand the provider’s business practices.

  • These discussions help clarify how services are delivered, documented, and billed.

  • Staff may be asked about scheduling processes, care coordination methods, billing workflows, or record‑keeping procedures.

5. Prepare Documentation Ahead of Time

  • Have all documentation needed to support billing and reimbursement organized and readily accessible, including:

  • Client records and progress notes

  • Treatment plans

  • Prior authorizations

  • Caregiver timesheets, service logs, or visit records

  • Any documentation required by regulation or policy to justify billed services

  • Auditors may need to photocopy or scan documents for their files. DPI maintains strict confidentiality for all records reviewed, including personnel files, payroll data, and contractor agreements.

6. Make Licensing and Business Credentials Available

  • Have current copies of:

  • Applicable business licenses

  • Professional healthcare licenses for relevant staff

  • Certifications or credentials related to the services under audit

  • Readiness in this area helps avoid delays and supports efficient verification.

     

  • Entrance Conference: The audit team conducts an Entrance Conference on the first day of the onsite audit. They will introduce themselves and provide general information about the audit process, billing instructions, DC Municipal Regulations (DCMR) that pertains to the audit. During the entrance conference, the provider should be prepared to introduce key office personnel and provide a tour of their facility. 

  • Onsite Work: The audit team makes copies of necessary documents/information, conducts key staff interviews, and reviews office processes. 

  • Exit Conference: The Exit Conference typically takes place on the last day of the audit. In limited circumstances an Exit Conference may be scheduled several weeks after the onsite audit. The audit lead conducts the Exit Conference with the provider and their key staff. It allows the audit team to ask any further clarifying questions and to discuss what the next steps in the audit process are with the provider. 

  • Post Onsite Visit: Upon completion of the onsite visit the provider can expect the review of medical and financial records to take 2-6 months depending on the nature and size of the review/audit. Any records still missing will be requested in a post-audit follow-up letter. The provider is required to mail any missing records to the Division of Program Integrity within 30 days of that letter. 

  • Surveillance/Utilization Branch Overpayment Notice: This notice provides information for both informal and formal dispute resolution processes. These processes must be requested no later than anywhere from 30 to 60 days (depending on the category of service being delivered and the specific regulations that govern that service) after the provider receives the overpayment notice. The informal process allows the provider to submit documentation to dispute the overpayment finding. If the Division of Program Integrity agrees with the documentation, the overpayment may be revised. Providers may access both the informal and formal dispute resolution processes simultaneously or choose one or the other. Accessing the informal process does not extend the 15-day timeframe for requesting a formal dispute resolution hearing.

Audit Timeline

Draft Report/Preliminary Clinical Review Notice Timeline: 

The average time from the onsite visit or formal request for records to issuance of the draft audit report or preliminary clinical review notice is three to six months 

Informal Dispute Timeline: 

If a provider disputes any draft or preliminary clinical review findings, they normally have thirty  calendar days, although 60 days for some provider types, from the date the draft audit report or preliminary clinical review notice is received to notify the Division of Program Integrity of what they are disputing. § 1306.4 of Title 29 DCMR

Final Report/Clinical Overpayment Notice Timeline: 

On average, the final audit report/clinical overpayment notice is issued within three months following the dispute process. 

Appeals Timeline: 

If a provider appeals the overpayment; they have 15 days from the receipt date of the final audit report or overpayment notice to request an adjudicative proceeding, also known as an “administrative hearing.” § 1307.8 of Title 29 DCMR

Who might receive a copy of the audit/review report? 

As stakeholders in the provider audit and review process Department of Health and Human Services, Attorney General’s Office, and/or Medicaid Fraud Control Unit may receive copies of audit/review reports and overpayment notices. Section § 1312.1 of Chapter 13 of Title 29 DCMR allow referral for disciplinary or criminal action if warranted.

As stakeholders in the provider audit and review process Department of Health and Human Services, Attorney General’s Office, and/or Medicaid Fraud Control Unit may receive copies of audit/review reports and overpayment notices. Section § 1312.1 of Chapter 13 of Title 29 DCMR allow referral for disciplinary or criminal action if warranted.

Audit Methodologies and Reporting 

The Division of Program Integrity uses several methodologies to select services or claims for audit or review. Each method is designed to identify billing irregularities, assess compliance, and ensure the integrity of Medicaid payments. The primary methodologies include:

1. Algorithm‑Based Selection

Advanced data analytics and algorithms are used to identify unusual billing patterns or statistical outliers.


This may include spikes in utilization, inconsistent units billed, abnormal provider‑to‑peer comparisons, or patterns indicative of potential fraud, waste, or abuse.

2. 100% Review of Claims for a Defined Time Period

In some cases, DPI will review all paid claims for a provider within a specific time frame.
This method is used when:

  • Significant concerns have been identified,

  • Billing patterns appear inconsistent with expected standards, or

  • A comprehensive review is needed to validate compliance across all services.

3. Random or Criteria‑Driven Claim Selection (Non‑Projected Findings)

DPI may select a set of claims based on predefined criteria such as:

  • Specific procedure codes,

  • High‑risk service categories,

  • Date ranges with known system or provider issues, or

  • Targeted review areas identified through complaint data or program trends.

A random sample may also be used for limited reviews.
These samples result in non‑projected findings, meaning the results apply only to the reviewed claims and are not extrapolated to the full universe.

4. Stratified Random Sampling for Extrapolation

For broader assessments, DPI may draw a stratified random statistical sample from the full universe of paid claims or procedures.
This approach groups claims into strata (e.g., by service type, cost, or frequency) and draws samples from each group to ensure representativeness.

When aberrant findings are identified, DPI may extrapolate the error rate to the full claim universe for that period — a method commonly used when widespread billing issues are suspected.

Purpose of These Methodologies

  • These selection methods help DPI:
  • Detect billing aberrancies early,
  • Measure compliance at both micro and macro levels,
  • Assess provider documentation practices,
  • Identify improper payments, and
  • Determine patterns that may require corrective action, education, or referral.

Audit Notification and Review Process 

Provider audits may be conducted with or without prior notice. Under Medical Assistance Program Transmittal #95‑47, the Division of Program Integrity (DPI) is authorized to perform certain unannounced onsite reviews when needed to validate provider compliance or investigate potential billing irregularities.

  • When audits are announced, DPI issues an intent‑to‑audit notification letter informing the provider of:

  • The upcoming audit,

  • The audit scope,

  • The time frame of the onsite review, and

  • Any initial documentation requirements.

Separately, DPI may send an overpayment notice if a completed review—either onsite or desk‑based—identifies improper payments. This notice outlines the basis for the overpayment determination and provides instructions for informal and formal dispute processes.

For audits initiated by federal program integrity entities—including PERM, UPIC, or RAC reviews—providers should refer to the Federal Audit Section of this guide for detailed information on expectations, timelines, and documentation requirements.

Documentation Requirements for Medicaid Audits

Medicaid providers must retain complete, accurate, and legible documentation that fully supports every service billed to Medicaid. During an audit or review, the Division of Program Integrity (DPI) may request a wide range of records to verify billing accuracy, service delivery, medical necessity, and compliance with District and federal requirements.

The following list reflects common types of documentation DPI may request.
This is not an exhaustive list, and additional records may be required depending on the audit scope:

Clinical and Medical Records

  • Prescription records

  • Office visit and hospital visit notes

  • Patient care plans and Prior Authorization documentation

  • Medication administration records/sheets

  • Diagnostic test results (e.g., laboratory reports, radiology or nuclear medicine results)

  • Physician or practitioner orders

  • Plans of Care

  • Treatment records

  • Complete hospital medical records

Financial, Billing, and Administrative Records

  • Financial reports, accounting documentation, billing records

  • Charge masters and service level descriptions

  • Credit balance reports

  • Third‑party insurance documentation

  • Appointment books and patient sign‑in sheets

  • Office/facility policies and employment records

  • Ownership agreements

  • Business licenses and professional staff licenses/certificates

Specialty or Procedure‑Specific Documentation

  • Dental x‑ray films

  • Surgical, recovery, and anesthesia records

  • Durable and non‑durable medical equipment delivery documents

  • Transfer records and referral documentation

Additional Notes for Providers

  • Providers are responsible for ensuring that all documentation is retained for the required period under District and federal regulations.

  • DPI may request originals or copies, including electronic records, depending on the nature of the audit.

  • Documentation must fully support billed claims, including medical necessity, correct coding, service delivery, provider credentials, and compliance with applicable policies.

  • Failure to produce requested records may result in recoupment of payments, audit findings, or administrative action.

Record Retention Requirements

Most Medicaid providers are required to maintain complete, accurate, and legible documentation in each client’s medical or health care service record for a minimum of six (6) years. This documentation must support the level, type, and extent of services billed.

Providers must ensure that:

  • Records are legible, complete, and accurate
    Documentation must fully justify every service billed to Medicaid.
  • Entries are properly authenticated
    Charts and records must be signed or otherwise authenticated by the individual who issued the order, provided the care, or performed the observation, examination, assessment, treatment, or other service documented.
  • Records are made available upon request
    Providers must produce charts and documentation to the Department of Health Care Finance (DHCF), its contractors, and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) for six years from the date of service, or longer when required by federal or state law.
    • Refer to the DC Municipal Regulations (DCMR) for specific requirements: http://www.dcregs.dc.gov/
    • Federal record‑keeping requirements can be found in Section 1902(a)(27) of the Social Security Act.

DHCF Provider Agreement Requirements (10‑Year Retention)

Under the DHCF Provider Agreement, providers must retain all original records and documents that support services billed and paid by DHCF for ten (10) years. This includes medical, administrative, billing, and financial documentation tied to Medicaid claims.

Retention During an Audit

If a provider is under audit or review, all records must be retained until the audit is fully completed and every issue is resolved, even if this extends beyond the standard six‑year or ten‑year retention periods.

Handling of Original Records During Onsite Audits

Audit staff do not remove original records from the provider’s possession.
During an onsite audit:

  • Auditors may make copies themselves, or

  • They may request that the provider make and supply copies of the original documents.

Providers remain responsible for maintaining custody and integrity of the originals at all times.

 

How Do I Get Audit Results?

 

Draft Audit Report/Preliminary Clinical Review Notice: Once the review of provider information and records is completed, the provider is mailed a draft audit report/preliminary clinical review notice. The provider is given 30 days to respond to the draft audit report/preliminary clinical review notice. 

Final Audit Report/Clinical Overpayment Notice: Once the draft audit/preliminary clinical review notice response time is expired or dispute process is completed, the final audit report/clinical overpayment notice is sent to the provider. This audit report/notice contains the final overpayment amount and directives. 

The Surveillance/Utilization Branch Overpayment Notice: When a Surveillance/Utilization Branch review or algorithm is completed, an overpayment notice may be issued. This notice contains the final overpayment amount and may contain directives. 

What dispute or appeal rights does a provider have in regards to the audit/review or overpayment notice findings? 

Draft audits/preliminary clinical review notices: § 1306.4 of Title 29 DCMR

  •  Providers have anywhere from 30 to 60 days (depending on the category of service being delivered and the specific regulations that govern that service) from receipt of the draft audit report or preliminary clinical review notice to dispute the draft audit or preliminary clinical review findings. Providers must submit the dispute in writing, include what findings they are contesting, and supply documentation to support their position. 

 Final audits/clinical overpayment: In accordance with § 1307.8 of Title 29 DCMR

  • Providers have 15 days from receipt of the final audit report/clinical review overpayment notice to request an administrative hearing/appeal of the final audit findings. Providers must submit the request in writing, including the basis for contesting the audit, and including a copy of the final audit report. The written request must be served in a manner which provides proof of receipt and must be sent to: 

Office of Administrative Hearing
441 4th Street, NW
Suite 450 – North
Washington, DC 20001-2714